Power Review: Yance Ford Provides a Detached, Academic Inquiry Into Policing

Netflixs Sundance-selected documentary essay which unpacks the history of American policing is highly detailed, but lacks rigor and force. Few issues have defined and divided the United States this decade like policing, and Yance Fords Power seeks to explore its origins. With few exceptions, the Netflix documentary/visual essay is more factual than emotional

Netflix’s Sundance-selected documentary essay — which unpacks the history of American policing — is highly detailed, but lacks rigor and force.

Few issues have defined and divided the United States this decade like policing, and Yance Ford’s “Power” seeks to explore its origins. With few exceptions, the Netflix documentary/visual essay is more factual than emotional — let alone revelatory in its examinations — but the film covers enough historical ground to function as a contemporary cinematic flashpoint, aimed at a wide audience who isn’t already steeped in its academic analyses (which have become a fixture of social media these last few years).

Ford provides both the interview questions (frequently interspersed with answers from various subjects) as well as the movie’s voiceover, which begins hesitantly and introspectively, warning the viewer about the breadth, scope and disturbing nature of the subject at hand. It isn’t so much a content warning as it is an act of solace; the filmmaker’s voice is gentle, and he’s ready to guide us through this tumultuous topic.

Related Stories

Photo collage of Lionsgate franchises The Hunger Games, Expendables, and Saw. VIP+

What Lionsgate’s Partnership Deal With Runway Means

Daveed Diggs

'The Boys' Season 5 Casts Daveed Diggs

Despite clocking in under an hour and a half, “Power” is jam-packed with context and footage detailing the multitude of precursors to modern American policing, forces conscripted to patrol and oppress Native Americans, Black slaves and poor workers (white and otherwise) in the 18th, 19th and early 20th centuries. The depth of this historical scrutiny is aimed at imagining a world without policing by reinforcing the way it has descended from malevolent forces, though the film seldom touches on the alternatives and their own academic history.

Popular on Variety

It does, however, conscript talking heads from various disciples at renowned universities
(plus two Black police officials) to help unearth some of this history. These interviews become the film’s de facto language, while its archival images — pulled from real events, fictional movies and even police instructional films — exist to support these subjects’ opinions and concerns. The film is, in this way, incredibly detailed, but its use of images is seldom piercing or affecting. The visuals always feel secondary to the subject.

Ford’s presence exists in conversation with the images regardless. Sometimes, this is literal. He occasionally comments on what’s being shown, and more vitally, what isn’t. The film blurs or blacks out several videos of contemporary police violence, especially when it might already be familiar to the audiences (e.g. the killing of George Floyd, the spark for nationwide demonstrations in 2020). Just as telling is the thematic conversation unfolding between the filmmaker and his subject matter, and his choice to hold back on certain footage and ideas.

The documentary that put Ford on the map, “Strong Island,” was exemplary in its intimacy, given the subject matter: the murder of Ford’s own brother. The filmmaker has proven more than capable of intimate presentation. While “Power” arrives at a multitude of conclusions about whose bodies have been policed throughout American history, the film curiously never touches on the policing of queerness and the way it ignited liberation movements at the same time as many of the fights for racial justice heavily featured in the film. Ford, as a transgender man, is more than likely familiar with that legacy, but the decision to take a top-down view of systemic violence also ends up being embodied by a sense of personal detachment in the filmmaking.

“Power” is far more observational than it is intimate (barring a brief interview with a repeated victim of New York’s draconian Stop-and-Frisk policy), in part because its subjects’ inner lives are rarely the focus. They exist largely to make verbal comments, rather than as vehicles for cinematic commentary. The film features a particularly revealing moment when Ford offers a follow-up question to one of these academics — an interrogation of her use of language, and what biases even she might hold — but the scene quickly moves on.

With its numerous chapter titles, “Power” seeks to take a macro look at American law enforcement, albeit while using a few micro examples to bolster its points with emotional arguments. The project’s far from sterile, but it feels reluctant to get its hands dirty by plunging them into the most raw and disturbing element of the subject: the violence itself — both the physical and psychological violence — which it seeks to frame as an inherent fixture of policing. Anyone watching the film is likely to learn something, though whether its lessons will stick, or claw their way beneath one’s skin, is less likely.

Read More About:

Jump to Comments

‘Power’ Review: Yance Ford Provides a Detached, Academic Inquiry Into Policing

Reviewed at Paris Theater, New York, Jan. 16, 2024. In Sundance Film Festival (Premieres). Running time: 86 MIN.

  • Production: (Documentary) A Netflix release. Producers: Swetha Vohra, Jess Devaney, Yance Ford, Netsanet Negussie. Executive producers: Nya Rous. Dan Cogan. Jon Bardin. Liz Garbus.
  • Crew: Director: Yance Ford. Camera: Julia Liu. Editor: Ian Olds. Music: Robert Aiki, Aubrey Lowe.
  • With: Charlie Adams, Baher Azmy, Paul Butler, Julian Go, Elizabeth Hinton, Redditt Hudson, Christy Lopez, Wesley Lowery, Stuard Schrader, Micol Seigel, Nikhil Pal Singh, Keeanga-Yamahatta Taylor, George Yancy.

More from Variety

Most Popular

Must Read

Sign Up for Variety Newsletters

By providing your information, you agree to our Terms of Use and our Privacy Policy.We use vendors that may also process your information to help provide our services. // This site is protected by reCAPTCHA Enterprise and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.

Variety Confidential

A Variety and iHeartRadio Podcast

ncG1vNJzZmiukae2psDYZ5qopV9nfXOAjp%2BgpaVfp7K3tcSwqmion6yys3nRnq2inadifnN%2FlHFub2tgZ3w%3D

 Share!